A source incentive label describes a reported relationship. It does not establish a review's truth, a purchase's independence or a supplement's effects.
Treat the label as context
An incentive can be something of value offered for a review. FTC guidance says that such relationships can affect the weight readers give an endorsement and should be disclosed when material. A review that mentions drawbacks can still need a disclosure. [1]
The label alone does not tell you the size of an incentive, the program's conditions or whether the writer's account is accurate. Read the disclosure and the actual observation. A specific account of capsule handling may still raise a useful practical question; a health claim still needs its own evidence.
Read true, false and unknown separately
Our published CoQ10 iHerb sample contains 55 included reviews: 52 carry a source incentive label and three are labeled false. These are the source's fields, not our independent investigation of a financial relationship. The sample is selected, so the split does not describe all reviews of that product. [2]
The separate NOW Glucomannan Amazon sample has 11 included reviews with incentive status unknown. That means the supplied metadata did not settle the field. It cannot be counted as 11 unincentivized reviews. A retailer purchase badge is also separate from independent purchase verification. [3]
Distinguish an incentive from a required positive review
The FTC's review-rule guidance distinguishes incentives for reviews from incentives conditioned, explicitly or implicitly, on a particular sentiment. Paying for a five-star review violates that rule even with disclosure. Other incentives can still raise disclosure and deception issues, and platform policies may be stricter. [4][5]
An incentive label on an individual review does not establish what a program required. Avoid accusing a reviewer of fabrication or claiming a retailer broke the law from that field alone. The guidance explains a distinction; our sample metadata cannot determine a program's compliance.
Use the information when reading a report
First read which reviews were supplied and retained. Then check the source labels and practical themes. Keep the sample denominator beside any count, and compare favorable accounts with concerns and uncertain results. A larger selected sample does not automatically remove selection bias.
For health claims, return to evidence about the relevant ingredient or finished formula. FTC guidance explains that consumer anecdotes cannot establish health effects. Neither a disclosure nor an apparently unincentivized review can replace that evidence. [6]
Sources & context
Follow the sources to explore their detail and limitations. Sources checked October 22, 2026; this is not a clinical review.
- FTC's Endorsement Guides: What People Are AskingFederal Trade Commission · Accessed October 22, 2026
- Doctor's Best CoQ10: published iHerb sample and label countsThe Biohack Pulse · 2026 · Accessed October 22, 2026
- NOW Glucomannan: published Amazon sample and label countsThe Biohack Pulse · 2026 · Accessed October 22, 2026
- Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule: Questions and AnswersFederal Trade Commission · Accessed October 22, 2026
- Soliciting and Paying for Online Reviews: A Guide for MarketersFederal Trade Commission · 2022 · Accessed October 22, 2026
- Health Products Compliance GuidanceFederal Trade Commission · 2022 · Accessed October 22, 2026
This guide uses metadata from our existing published review reports to explain labels. It adds no newly collected review sample and offers no product testing, rankings or clinical review. Read our approach and disclosures.